Would you have preferred if Sulani was a vacation world?

Yes and no. I would really love the option to have rentable lots in all worlds as was possible in Sims 2 and 3. Or even better, have actual hotels. I loved hotels in Sims 2.

I’m on the fence about this one. I didn’t participate in the vote because I don’t actually own Island Living yet so I can’t give it a fair opinion, but I was really disappointed when it was released as a full on expansion pack and not a game pack/vacation world. I’ve been hoping for a tropical vacation world to be released. However, that being said, I also think it’s cool that it is a full world and I love that it comes with mermaids. I agree with @Rhiannon1307 that I wish it at least had the option for rentals. Who knows, maybe in a future stuff or game pack or patch they’ll give us hotels.

No. I just don’t use vacation worlds as much.
I would have preferred rental lots and second homes to have been an option.

I’m still hopeful that we will get a hotel game pack

I wish we had the option of assigning it as either. I personally prefer it as a vacation destination after playing with it for a while.

I have one lot set up as a spa, but it also is set up for any of my sims who don't live there to come and stay for a visit. So it is possible to have this as a vacation location, but I am very happy that my sims can live there as well. I would not change this part one bit.

Having an expansion pack being a vacation world would be unacceptable to me.

Also I find it interesting how many people bring this up since the common reaction is the opposite, people being extremely disappointed Jungle Adventure doesn't have live in lots.

"Beardedgeek;c-17150845" wrote:
Having an expansion pack being a vacation world would be unacceptable to me.

Also I find it interesting how many people bring this up since the common reaction is the opposite, people being extremely disappointed Jungle Adventure doesn't have live in lots.

I was one of those people. :)

No, I don't like it when they turn the most beautiful worlds into vacation destinations like they did with Granite Falls and Selvadorada.

No, I wish we could live in the vacation spots we already have and it's generally a hassle to go on vacation with your Sim anyway.
I wish there was an option to do a sort of AirBnB or B&B, if not proper hotel.
It could be a freelance job, or there could be an option to make money by having a tenant.

No. I like my sims being able to live there or have easy access to community lots or even private housing (with the always welcome trait basically making it their home too).
I hope in the future we get a lot type that allows me to make B&B's or motels (simple rentals). I don't think resorts would run well if implemented. I hope if they do it they keep it manageable.