Forum Discussion

CoIbyHawkins's avatar
2 years ago

Console graphics feedback

Hello everyone! This is my reddit post link I've originally posted this on. If you don't want to be redirected to Reddit, I have copy&pasted the contents of the said post below: 

https://www.reddit.com/r/EASPORTSWRC/comments/17l9xn9/my_second_take_on_console_graphics/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3



So, the early access is already here and the game will be "officially' out in two days.

 

Gameplay is sick and highly addictive, there is no denying about that. It's amazing.

 

I want the game to improve because it's a good, enjoyable and addictive rally game, so don't take this post as hating, because it's not.

 

Back to the graphics though:

While maxed out PC settings can look good on high resolution (but stutters like hell), the game really lacks in the graphics department on console(s).

As I only have a PS5 right now, I will comment about the PS5 mainly, but I reckon the same can be applied to XSX.

I know the game runs on Unreal Engine 4 (? from what I know it's UE4, not 5, need confirmation to be 110% sure), but it's totally disappointing how the game looks on PS5 regardless of the used game development engine.

 

We were told the console version will be equal or almost equal to the High preset and target 4K60.

 

While there are significantly less performance problems on the PS5 (occasional stutters, frame drops and screen tearing with VRR enabled are all present and still need work), the render resolution and texture resolution are both seriously bad, and it's not even nitpicking from me. The only thing rendered in 4K is the UI I believe, but just like in other console games (besides some native 4K gems, but they run in 30, 40 and only sometimes in 60fps modes) we probably shouldn't expect native 4K with a 100% render scale here.

 

My main problem is with the resolutionrender scale and environmental texture resolution.

 

Cars look okay-ish, but once you see everything around the car on the stage, it can't be unseen.

While I am not an expert in game graphics, these are things you can spot almost immediately after starting any stage that is not covered in snow. Foliage and ground textures look like they were taken from Microsoft Flight Simulator, where you don't see them most of the time and when you see them you immediately regret that you decided to do so. You get the point.

I also think the game completely lacks ambient occlusion? I might be wrong here, but it all looks rather flat.

 

And the look of these stages at night?

These kind of graphics should be allowed only on Halloween. I hope it's an inside dev joke, because preorder early access released on Halloween and we will get our quality graphics back in a patch :D

 

Why it's so important?

Foliage and ground textures are the main antagonists in the lore of sim rally in general, so we have constant contact with them and see them 100% of the time while rallying.

 

Here are my screenshots (no, it's not bad screenshot quality, it's how I see the game live on my 4K TV).

 

Make sure you open them on your PC, so you can see the details I'm talking about:
 

Water splash (my favorite! last time I've seen this kind of graphic fidelity in Tomb Raider 2 pools :D):

  1. https://i.imgur.com/JlcKzFG.jpg

Night-time photos:

  1. https://i.imgur.com/0P1yiTY.jpg

  2. https://i.imgur.com/CPxVrCI.jpg

  3. https://i.imgur.com/AOevoh5.jpg

  4. https://i.imgur.com/9Fhx5t7.jpg

Daytime photos:

  1. https://i.imgur.com/jpwPeNO.jpg

  2. https://i.imgur.com/IuJqfvV.jpg

  3. https://i.imgur.com/okyHl1x.jpg

  4. https://i.imgur.com/wtZaXYJ.jpg

  5. https://i.imgur.com/BPQFfLm.jpg

 

 

Can we have any feedback from EA / Codemasters regarding this?

20 Replies

  • EA_Groguet's avatar
    EA_Groguet
    Icon for Community Manager rankCommunity Manager
    2 years ago

    Hey there,

    Thank you everyone for your comments and thanks @CoIbyHawkins for such an extensive message and explanation.

    This message has been raised to the team and they are aware of the sentiment around it.

    Thank you for your feedback.

  • Such a great shame regarding the line tearing etc. I pre-ordered but wish I hadn't, for now I'm going back to Dirt 2.0

    Hopefully we'll see a patch soon.

  • I agree with everything

    The PS5 can do much better than this
    I really like the gameplay of the game... but in the visual aspect, Codemasters needs to do more, much more !!!
    I have the impression that the game is sometimes inferior to Dirt Rally 2.0... besides, this game hasn't even been released on PS4 and Xbox One.
    What happened here anyway?

    Well, good luck with the patches, I really hope they bring big improvements !!! I really like you guys and I believe you can sort this out

  • I fully agree. This graphic quality would have been good when it was for the PSVR2 headset, But having these graphics as flatscreen PS5 quality is somewhat to be ashamed for as a developer in 2023.

  • Kona_uk's avatar
    Kona_uk
    Seasoned Ace
    2 years ago

    It has to be the worst i have seen it's so bad you cannot stop looking at how bad the graphics are.

    Looking at the grass & tree assets i would say they are equal to wrc 5 in 2015

  • I you have a PS5 then go to the VRR settings and enable the setting which forces VRR even if the game doesn't support it. I found this makes a huge difference to the line tearing. 

  • I've played the trial on PC version (through game pass EA play) then bought it on the PS5... this is night and day difference.. the resolution is so low like 1200p at best. I WANT A REFUND!

  • LariosoDog's avatar
    LariosoDog
    2 years ago

    @FranciscoSlb24 wrote:

    I agree with everything

    The PS5 can do much better than this
    I really like the gameplay of the game... but in the visual aspect, Codemasters needs to do more, much more !!!
    I have the impression that the game is sometimes inferior to Dirt Rally 2.0... besides, this game hasn't even been released on PS4 and Xbox One.
    What happened here anyway?

    Well, good luck with the patches, I really hope they bring big improvements !!! I really like you guys and I believe you can sort this out


    Agree, I still have Dirt 2 under my chair on a Xbox 360 and that is the first impression I got from the game yesterday as installed, v1.8 fresh and all.

    Are there any graphics settings at all?

    I looked in Xbox store, and it does not say 4k at all, so not 4k, but one would expect 1080p, not 720p look.

About WRC General Discussion

Discuss the latest news and game information around EA SPORTS™ WRC in the community forums.1,508 PostsLatest Activity: 8 hours ago