[AA] Critter Hunter: Go Fishing with Buddy only works with household members

This is also happening for me on Xbox Series X with all content installed. My Sim is in a solo household and though I'm selecting Go fishing with and Invite to go fishing it's not checking off. I've tried many many times but it's not working.

Hello, whoever reads this.

During the second part of the Critter Hunter aspiration, my Sim must fish with a "buddy". That step won't complete for me. Right now, I'm re-installing the game in the hopes it will help somehow. No matter if I have my Sim join an already fishing Sim or invite a Sim to come fish with mine, it just won't complete for any of my Sims. Please help.

Nindigo79

There has been some issues with doing this. Try doing it with a household member and see if that helps.

I thought I heard that this is done via archery? Like level 4 to archery bowfishing with buddy, but maybe I am wrong.

That did the trick, rosemow. Thank you so much😍

This has been reported as a bug so if you're experiencing this issue please upvote.
[AA] Critter Hunter: Go Fishing with Buddy only works with household members | EA Forums - 12701233

Done and thank you.

Same! I've been stuck on this for days and finally decided to hit the forum. I ended up just cheat adding a sim to my single sim household and bam, yep, it works. I had tried over and over with my sim's friends and strangers to no avail. 

I have no mods installed, Mac, only testing cheats enabled