I agree with the analysis of the problem, but not with the proposed solution: the roof camping on that map was utterly obnoxious at release, I don’t want to see it back unless they rework the buildings’ interiors to give alternative roof access. And let’s be honest, that’s never going to happen.
The problem is simple: you could only access the roofs through chopper. Once your own chopper was down, you couldn’t go and challenge the enemy. And with objs being stupid squares on the ground, a couple of guys on a roof were be enough to defend an obj all game. I know, I did it many times. And I’m not a pilot and I posted a long post here complaining about it
But yes, removing the roofs means that infantry has zero counter play to choppers on this map. So I just want to see the choppers gone. I understand they thought it’d be cool to have choppers in the New York sky, but it clearly doesn’t work, they need to go.