Purchased addons not syncing; demanding I pay for them again

I loaded up EA on my new PC. I purchased Spore along with galactic adventures and Creepy and Cute add-ons on my old laptop. In the app on the new one I am able to access only the former 2; Galactic adventures can't run without Creepy and Cute, which is listed in my add-ons but demanding I pay for it again. I have tried uninstalling the games, clearing the cache and program files, restarting the PC and reinstalling: all to no avail. Please advise.