FC 24 Two Player Control Issues

Hi,

hope somebody can help with the following issue:

System: XBox Series X / Game: EA FC 24 / Issue: Controller Setting using 2 local controller (one Elite 2 and one Series X Controller)

Today I wanted to play FC 24 with a friend doing a local match (Kick Off with two Controller).

Following Issue, I am playing classic settings on the controller the friend of mine is playing alternative, thats where the nightmare began.

We changed the settings for Controller 2 into alternative, system asked us if we want to save. We used the empty space to save the settings. We started the game but the settings were not changed (still classic on both controllers). We entered the settings again (already in a match) it changed both controllers into alterantive settings.

We tried it for at least one hour in different ways to have controller 1 in classic mode and controller 2 in alternative after 1 hour it worked for one match but the setting stepped back into classic after and it was again not possible to do the settings.

I googled for a fix/work around, seems others have the same problem (even on other systems like PS) but there is no temp or perm solution

We have changed the Controllers from 1st to 2nd and from 2nd to 1st. We have connected another Controller (XBox one) we created another Profile for Controller 2 and tried the Guest account tried to connect the controller with the USB-C cable. Nothing worked! I never faced such an issue with any other Game.

Is there any solution for this problem I was not thinking about or I did not find online?

Thanks for your feedback.