Broken Leaderboards in Clubs (and Seasons)
Can one of the moderators please explain how the Clubs leaderboards are actually supposed to work this year? EA_Darko EA_Vendcera
Because right now, they appear completely broken.
I’ve logged 2000+ matches as an ANY in Clubs, and somehow I’m still showing as unranked on the global leaderboard, which simply makes no sense. There is no scenario where that should be happening if the tracking is functioning correctly.
Beyond that, a huge number of the leaderboard stats are clearly nonsense. You’ll see players with things like 1.7 million interceptions in ~2000 matches, absurd numbers that are obviously impossible. That completely destroys any legitimacy the leaderboards are supposed to have.
So genuine question: what is the actual algorithm / qualification criteria for appearing on these boards?
- Is there a minimum match threshold?
- How does the system weigh goals, assists, passing percentage, etc.?
- ANY tracking works differently from individual positions - how so?
- Are stats delayed / cached / bugged?
Because from the outside looking in, the entire system feels completely unreliable.
Also, there’s STILL another long-standing issue that hasn’t been addressed:
Friends stat comparisons do not work at all - in either Pro Leaderboard or Club Leaderboard
If you try comparing Clubs stats with friends (and/or their respective squads) through the leaderboards, it simply never loads. Same issue in Seasons as well. It’s just broken. This has been a problem all year.
At this point, EA really needs to:
- Clarify how leaderboard ranking actually works
- Fix the friend comparison functionality both for the individual and club leaderboards
- Audit / clean the obviously false leaderboard stats
- Reprocess legitimate player stats so actual active players are properly ranked
Leaderboards are supposed to be competitive content. Right now they feel meaningless.
