Forum Discussion

strbje's avatar
strbje
New Novice
4 months ago

Pro Clubs needs real analytics.

I’ve been running a national Pro Clubs league for ~3 years and I built an independent analytics stack for Clubs (11v11). I collect match data, publish player radarsteam style profiles, and match reports, and I use advanced metrics the game doesn’t provide: pXA (passes per 0.5 xA), Beaten Rate (%), Safety Index, Shot Danger, verticality (shots-per-pass), pressing intensity, aerial dominance and more. I’m looking for feedback, collaborators, and data-driven discussion.

Why this matters
Clubs has no official API and almost no advanced stats. Beyond G/A, captains and coaches fly blind. My goal is to surface decision quality and off-ball impact so teams can recruit, prepare, and improve with evidence — not just vibes. In our league, we collected statistics through video recordings and uploaded them to the website.

Core metrics (short definitions)

  • pXA — passes needed to generate 0.5 xA. Lower is better (creative efficiency).
  • Beaten Rate (%) — % of defensive situations where a player is beaten. Lower is better (resilience).
  • Safety Index — share of actions taken under low pressure/safe choices. Higher = safer style.
  • Shot Danger — danger proxy for shots (location/context). Higher = closer/better body-shape.
  • Shots per goal — finishing efficiency proxy (lower = fewer shots needed).
  • Shot accuracy — on-target share.
  • Pressing intensity (per 90) — tackles + interceptions; tiers: >3.0 high, 1.8–3.0 above avg, 1.0–1.8 avg, <1.0 low.
  • Aerial win % / Clearances / Blocks — backline sturdiness.
  • Possession share by player — % of team passes to identify playmakers vs finishers.
  • Cross volume & accuracy — for wide roles (with thresholds to avoid noise).
  • Finishing vs xG — over/under-performance relative to shot quality.
  • And etc.

What I do with it

  • Team scouting: style fingerprints (direct vs combinational, flank vs central creation).
  • Role clarity: separating creators, carriers, anchors, target men.
  • Weekly leaderboards and post-match reports for community engagement.
  • Draft events with objective seeding and role balancing.
  • Player radars (I can send you examples.).
  • League analytics and more

What’s unique

  • Built for Clubs (11v11), not FUT/1v1 logic.
  • Consistent role templates per position with fixed metric order & interpretation.
  • Threshold rules (e.g., crosses ≥15 attempts; shooting stats shown only with meaningful volume) to prevent small-sample noise.
  • Public write-ups + dashboards; constant validation with teams and captains.

Looking for

  • Captains/analysts: I need your opinion on how necessary it really is
  • Devs/researchers: let’s discuss an ETL and privacy-friendly pipeline for Clubs data.
  • EA folks: I’m happy to share the spec and community results to help push Clubs analytics forward.

8 Replies

  • ACM-Nyko's avatar
    ACM-Nyko
    Seasoned Novice
    3 months ago

    Hi mate,

    We're developing a pro clubs, please reach out to me on discord: jareth99

  • This is incredible! How are you collecting the stats through the videos reliably?

    This was my attempt at collecting all the detailed stats the game provides in FC 25. 

    https://github.com/Regista6/EA-FC-Clubs-Stat-Extract

  • strbje's avatar
    strbje
    New Novice
    31 days ago

    As a league administrator, I used hired statisticians to control the recording of videos according to the format described in the regulations. They entered the numbers from the videos into a special form on the website. The method of entering data using screenshots is time-consuming, as players must do it, which is much more difficult than recording a one-minute video.

  • watch_dogs155's avatar
    watch_dogs155
    New Novice
    29 days ago

    My discord is: watchdogs132. I would love to discuss about this in more detail if that's ok. 

  • strbje's avatar
    strbje
    New Novice
    7 days ago

    It looks great, I'm also making my own local website with advanced statistics, which the EASports API doesn't provide right now. But what you have on your website can also be improved. I am ready to cooperate with you, as I see that we are pursuing identical goals.

  • mollart's avatar
    mollart
    Rising Newcomer
    6 days ago

    I get an email everyweek with this offer. What are you actually offering to do?

  • strbje's avatar
    strbje
    New Novice
    2 days ago

    I'm making a similar website, but now I have more statistical indicators, because in our league we collect them manually, thanks to which I was able to make advanced indicators.

    I can help, for example, to make advanced statistical indicators from what is available now, to highlight the ranges of players by various indicators, and so on. I can show you what I have on my website now.

     

Featured Places

Node avatar for FC 26 General Discussion

FC 26 General Discussion

Discuss the latest news and game information around EA SPORTS FC™ 26 in the community forums.Latest Activity: 26 days ago
4,259 Posts