Asajj as a Sith?

"Mithrawnuodo;832433" wrote:
Wow.
So many argue.
Much questions.
Wowe.

That said...
The rule of two. This argument needs to go out the window immediately, based on what IS canon.
Sid was definitely training more than one apprentice at a time, no question.
The RIGHT question is, according to canon lore, what constitutes a Sith?
In order to become a Sith....
Train under a Sith.
One isn't considered a true Sith until performing one specific act, dependent on the supplicant, the act being to several ties with one's prevous life, through the cold murder of one's closest personal tie(s) to their previous life. In Sid's case, he murdered his parents. In Anakin's case, it was "killing" Padme. Maul, I dunno. Same for Savage, or Assaj. And I've no proof Dooku ever finished formal training either. It gets complicated there, but what we do know is they were all at least partially trained... and in some way could at least be called Sith assassins, but probably not full Sith.
As to whether Assaj fits as a Sith...
I don't think she quite counts, as she wasn't trained by a full Sith. The weak link is, of course, whether Dooku should count, but I'm assuming he does, as Palpatine referred to him as Darth Tyrannosaurus, and Maul as Darth Maul.
But, like I said, it's complicated...

Count Dooku, its already in his name ... he counts! :lol: j/k

I want to add, that Savage killed his own Brother, but it was when he was with the Nightsisters, so ... does this count, or not?

Sid was training more than one apprentice at a time? Who? When? I havnt noticed something like that in any movie.

The rule of two imo is not a optional guildline only, but really a Sith internal law ... However, if there is a law that says you are only allowed to drive 50 km/h, you still can drive 60, 70, or whatever ... so is it also possible that there are more then just 2 Sith's at a time, but its just not allowed, what leads Sid to "clear" the situation by defeating Maul and Savage. Sure, you can say hey, the rule of two is just a fake to hide sid (when Bane made it), because Jedi thought Dooku is the master and Asajj the apprentice ... as far as i remember, it was never confirmed by any movie/series if its a fake rule, or a real sith internal rule.