Asajj as a Sith?

"Boo;832210" wrote:

Having said that - she was a sith. Not a sixth lord but was certainly a sith assassin and was apprentice to Dooku so she should have a correct label as sith as well as nightsister and separatist. So what if the list as long, as long as the list is correct.

If that's the case Jedi knight anakin should have the sith tag as well. He turned to the dark side & became sids apprentice. We can nitpick with a lot of characters. Asajj isn't a sith just face it. Asajj in game is the Asajj that return to the nightsisters.

"DarthAl;832237" wrote:

"Boo;832210" wrote:

Having said that - she was a sith. Not a sixth lord but was certainly a sith assassin and was apprentice to Dooku so she should have a correct label as sith as well as nightsister and separatist. So what if the list as long, as long as the list is correct.

If that's the case Jedi knight anakin should have the sith tag as well. He turned to the dark side & became sids apprentice. We can nitpick with a lot of characters. Asajj isn't a sith just face it. Asajj in game is the Asajj that return to the nightsisters.

That's not what her outfit says...

"DarthAl;832237" wrote:

"Boo;832210" wrote:

Having said that - she was a sith. Not a sixth lord but was certainly a sith assassin and was apprentice to Dooku so she should have a correct label as sith as well as nightsister and separatist. So what if the list as long, as long as the list is correct.

If that's the case Jedi knight anakin should have the sith tag as well. He turned to the dark side & became sids apprentice. We can nitpick with a lot of characters. Asajj isn't a sith just face it. Asajj in game is the Asajj that return to the nightsisters.

Also, JKA was never Sith. Upon accepting Sidious' offer to become his apprentice Sid renamed him Darth Vader. He was DV the entire time he was affiliated with Sith.

"Achilles;830276" wrote:

"DarthBisharp;830246" wrote:
Assaj was never a sith. She was merely a tool to sell that Dooku was actually the 'master'. She wasn't even trained in the ways of the sith, she had a bit of dark side training from Dooku and became his assassin.
That being said though, Maul was the same. He was never actually trained as a sith, just a weapon for the dark side to use before being cast aside. And yet he has the tag so who knows what factors contribute to who gets tagged as what in this game.

Swap "Maul" with "Savage" and i agree! ;)

Even though Savage could count as a Sith, since Maul took him as Apprentice and trained him as Sith, however, there is the "rule of two" and there was already a rival due (Sidious and Dooku), but well ... for a short time, both duos claimed the title to be the true Siths ... (until sid visited Maul and Savage and assured them, they are not ;) )

He admitted they were "competition".
How are they not sith?

"ItsJarJarBinkz;832044" wrote:

"Annastrasza;832025" wrote:

"Mojavelandbaron;830232" wrote:
Wholeheartedly agree! Just like some characters have both designations like "Scoundrel, Rebel", Assaj's really should be "Nightsister, Sith".

Dooku trained Maul is Sith...so why not Asajj.

It would excellent to include Asajj in a all
Sith team.

Dooku didn't train maul. Sid did

You got me!
So yes I did some research and the conclusion is that Asajj does not qualify as Sith due to the "two rule".

Asajj was trained to be a Sith by Dooku but she did not complete her trainings/ tasks hence is not an official apprentice aka not a Sith.

Asajj is more of a Dark Jedi or Sith Aspirant.

Case closed.

"Annastrasza;832344" wrote:

So yes I did some research and the conclusion is that Asajj does not qualify as Sith due to the "two rule".

Asajj was trained to be a Sith by Dooku but she did not complete her trainings/ tasks hence is not an official apprentice aka not a Sith.

Asajj is more of a Dark Jedi or Sith Aspirant.

Case closed.

So where do you draw the line then, and why? Savage is a Sith because Maul proclaimed himself a master and said Savage was his apprentice, but they were never really a threat. Sid walked right into their stronghold and wrecked them without any concern or backup.

Ventress on the other hand, he instructed Dooku to get rid of her because he saw the two of them as a potential threat (and I'm pretty sure he straight up accused Dooku of taking her on as an apprentice though I'll have to rewatch that to confirm or deny).

So where is the line? Does just saying it make it so? Becuase I'm pretty sure she probably considered herself Sith at the time.

Plus any justification using the rule as an absolute is shaky at best. It was routinely ignored or seen as a mere guideline, and it did a terrible job of accomplishing any of the goals it was meant to.

What Sid did with Savage and Asajj is pure politics.

"Annastrasza;832344" wrote:

"ItsJarJarBinkz;832044" wrote:

"Annastrasza;832025" wrote:

"Mojavelandbaron;830232" wrote:
Wholeheartedly agree! Just like some characters have both designations like "Scoundrel, Rebel", Assaj's really should be "Nightsister, Sith".

Dooku trained Maul is Sith...so why not Asajj.

It would excellent to include Asajj in a all
Sith team.

Dooku didn't train maul. Sid did

You got me!
So yes I did some research and the conclusion is that Asajj does not qualify as Sith due to the "two rule".

Asajj was trained to be a Sith by Dooku but she did not complete her trainings/ tasks hence is not an official apprentice aka not a Sith.

Asajj is more of a Dark Jedi or Sith Aspirant.

Case closed.

The official star wars site begs to differ. Her affiliation is very clearly 'Nightsister, Sith'.

"Mithrawnuodo;832433" wrote:
.

As to whether Assaj fits as a Sith...
I don't think she quite counts, as she wasn't trained by a full Sith. The weak link is, of course, whether Dooku should count, but I'm assuming he does, as Palpatine referred to him as Darth Tyrannosaurus, and Maul as Darth Maul.
But, like I said, it's complicated...

I dunno, If he has the title of Darth I'm gonna call him a true Sith. I'd definitely consider Dooku to be more so than Maul, so if Maul's apprentice is a Sith then why not Dooku's?

But yeah, totally agree the Rule of Two argument is a bad argument.

"Boo;832210" wrote:


Also, JKA was never Sith. Upon accepting Sidious' offer to become his apprentice Sid renamed him Darth Vader. He was DV the entire time he was affiliated with Sith.

I know that.lol just showing how people are nitpicking.