"Starslayer;c-2418152" wrote:
"Ragnarok_COTF;c-2418147" wrote:
People don't like the squish. They feel like something is being taken away from them. Being relegated after a win is the perfect epitome of their frustrations. Just because CG could have made it worse by instantly relegating doesn't mean people can't voice their frustrations with the current system.
While it may not be your intent, your comment implies a defense of the current system.
https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Not_as_bad_as
A ‘Lesser of 2 evil’ approach shouldn’t be mistaken for a ‘Not as bad’ fallacy.
For the record, if being demoted because of the squish is the price to pay to keep division size regulated, I don’t mind. I just wish they could solve the very specific problem of K1 shrinking.
It very clearly is not a "lesser of 2 evils" argument because the scenario ANH mentions is entirely hypothetical, and the solutions available to us are not binary.
Furthermore, his stated position has not been challenged by anyone, only the implication of it, and only because he insisted on repeating it.