Forum Discussion
73 Replies
"Timitock;256006" wrote:
"Telaan;255964" wrote:
"Timitock;255935" wrote:
I repeat, guilds are drama.
People want guilds because they want to be "in charge".
I repeat, guilds already exist.
Added Guild UI adds little to the game.
This is not an MMO, and guilds are not in other similar games (MAA for instance).
The nagging question is:
"Why introduce us to the Hutt in the tutorial, then tell us we will meet again, then show him sitting at a table with SHIPS, then mention SHIPS in Biggs' bio, only to not have SHIPS?
Also, you said yourself, ships are the #1 most requested feature.
So your counter is basically "nuh uh. It's just drama."
Guilds exist as a means of providing more content thorough both GvG and GvE events/tournaments. Your anti-guild agenda and use of e-bullying as the justification to exclude this feature doesn't change this fact. Guilds and guild based events also exist in many mobile games. I provided you with just one in my above post. The fact that this isn't an MMO is irrelevant. Guilds exist cross-genre and platform and often serve specific functions. You've got to be one of the worst trolls ever if you think that you can stand by your "just want to be in charge" statement. Lol
What information do you have that a competitive ladder wouldn't exist for ships? What information do you have that ships may not be a guild based feature? What information do you have on ships at all? The answer is you don't have any info on it what-so-ever. I also never stated that ships were the number one feature requested. I specifically said both were one of the most highly requested features.
Drama.
Game, set, match.
I'd rather have ships, but @Telaan is killing you in this argument."Telaan;255964" wrote:
"Timitock;255935" wrote:
I repeat, guilds are drama.
People want guilds because they want to be "in charge".
I repeat, guilds already exist.
Added Guild UI adds little to the game.
This is not an MMO, and guilds are not in other similar games (MAA for instance).
The nagging question is:
"Why introduce us to the Hutt in the tutorial, then tell us we will meet again, then show him sitting at a table with SHIPS, then mention SHIPS in Biggs' bio, only to not have SHIPS?
Also, you said yourself, ships are the #1 most requested feature.
So your counter is basically "nuh uh. It's just drama."
Guilds exist as a means of providing more content thorough both GvG and GvE events/tournaments. Your anti-guild agenda and use of e-bullying as the justification to exclude this feature doesn't change this fact. Guilds and guild based events also exist in many mobile games. I provided you with just one in my above post. The fact that this isn't an MMO is irrelevant. Guilds exist cross-genre and platform and often serve specific functions. You've got to be one of the worst trolls ever if you think that you can stand by your "just want to be in charge" statement. Lol
What information do you have that a competitive ladder wouldn't exist for ships? What information do you have that ships may not be a guild based feature? What information do you have on ships at all? The answer is you don't have any info on it what-so-ever. I also never stated that ships were the number one feature requested. I specifically said both were one of the most highly requested features.
So much drama pal...go play another game that has these guilds you so dearly need.
Does every post you make have to be some opinionated statement?"Telaan;255827" wrote:
That's a huge stretch. Doubtful. Guilds > ships anyway.
I think it is a shorter stretch than guilds. I think it is silly to have a Star Wars game without space battles. That being said I don't know why we can't have both ships and guilds.
I liked your idea of the two actually being tied together and the only reason I wouldn't want guilds is because I'm not in one lol. Obviously if they released guilds and there were exclusive events/rewards I would join one ASAP.
The player base as a whole is starving for new content that they have been promising forever so if they added either ships or guilds with something to do besides talk then that is a good thing. Sadly I am not very optimistic and I think that if it was either guilds or ships they would've hyped it more. Just my 2 cents."Timitock;256047" wrote:
Biggest reason ships come before guilds: they can SELL ships.
'Bigg'est.
Censorship continues to amaze me."KamikazeRhombus;256045" wrote:
"Telaan;255827" wrote:
That's a huge stretch. Doubtful. Guilds > ships anyway.
I think it is a shorter stretch than guilds. I think it is silly to have a Star Wars game without space battles. That being said I don't know why we can't have both ships and guilds.
I liked your idea of the two actually being tied together and the only reason I wouldn't want guilds is because I'm not in one lol. Obviously if they released guilds and there were exclusive events/rewards I would join one ASAP.
The player base as a whole is starving for new content that they have been promising forever so if they added either ships or guilds with something to do besides talk then that is a good thing. Sadly I am not very optimistic and I think that if it was either guilds or ships they would've hyped it more. Just my 2 cents.
I largely agree. I'm fairly confident both are goals for the Devs. The questions are how long do we have to wait and in what order will they come. I think SWFC really does its guild/legion system right. The events are a lot of fun and provide good rewards that participate but aren't game breaking for those that don't. It provides a sense of cooperation/teamwork and competition that this game currently lacks.
I definitely want ships too and I agree that the prospect of them being included in GvG gameplay would be a ton of fun.- Lol, no guilds or ships! Look at what a simple word can do to people's imagination. You need to lower your expectations.
"Timitock;256006" wrote:
"Telaan;255964" wrote:
"Timitock;255935" wrote:
I repeat, guilds are drama.
People want guilds because they want to be "in charge".
I repeat, guilds already exist.
Added Guild UI adds little to the game.
This is not an MMO, and guilds are not in other similar games (MAA for instance).
The nagging question is:
"Why introduce us to the Hutt in the tutorial, then tell us we will meet again, then show him sitting at a table with SHIPS, then mention SHIPS in Biggs' bio, only to not have SHIPS?
Also, you said yourself, ships are the #1 most requested feature.
So your counter is basically "nuh uh. It's just drama."
Guilds exist as a means of providing more content thorough both GvG and GvE events/tournaments. Your anti-guild agenda and use of e-bullying as the justification to exclude this feature doesn't change this fact. Guilds and guild based events also exist in many mobile games. I provided you with just one in my above post. The fact that this isn't an MMO is irrelevant. Guilds exist cross-genre and platform and often serve specific functions. You've got to be one of the worst trolls ever if you think that you can stand by your "just want to be in charge" statement. Lol
What information do you have that a competitive ladder wouldn't exist for ships? What information do you have that ships may not be a guild based feature? What information do you have on ships at all? The answer is you don't have any info on it what-so-ever. I also never stated that ships were the number one feature requested. I specifically said both were one of the most highly requested features.
Drama.
Game, set, match.
Hardly game, set or match. So dramatic. Opinions are not a compition.
I am really sorry you have had trouble with guild drama. If you find a group of like minded people guilds can greatly enhance the value and the fun of the game for everyone in the guild and the game.
It's kind of like forums, or even a thread.. There is always someone that says something just for the shock value, or to disagree with a popular opinion in order to cause drama. :/"Timitock;256073" wrote:
"ioniancat21;256062" wrote:
@Timitock is joking with you clearly about guilds being trouble. I recall seeing a post from him asking for Guilds in fact....
SHUT UP SHUT UP SHUT UP!
I was having fun!
Now imagine me in Guild Chat...
It would be very dramatic. :|"Timitock;256047" wrote:
"Wildcats1203;256024" wrote:
"Timitock;256006" wrote:
"Telaan;255964" wrote:
"Timitock;255935" wrote:
I repeat, guilds are drama.
People want guilds because they want to be "in charge".
I repeat, guilds already exist.
Added Guild UI adds little to the game.
This is not an MMO, and guilds are not in other similar games (MAA for instance).
The nagging question is:
"Why introduce us to the Hutt in the tutorial, then tell us we will meet again, then show him sitting at a table with SHIPS, then mention SHIPS in Biggs' bio, only to not have SHIPS?
Also, you said yourself, ships are the #1 most requested feature.
So your counter is basically "nuh uh. It's just drama."
Guilds exist as a means of providing more content thorough both GvG and GvE events/tournaments. Your anti-guild agenda and use of e-bullying as the justification to exclude this feature doesn't change this fact. Guilds and guild based events also exist in many mobile games. I provided you with just one in my above post. The fact that this isn't an MMO is irrelevant. Guilds exist cross-genre and platform and often serve specific functions. You've got to be one of the worst trolls ever if you think that you can stand by your "just want to be in charge" statement. Lol
What information do you have that a competitive ladder wouldn't exist for ships? What information do you have that ships may not be a guild based feature? What information do you have on ships at all? The answer is you don't have any info on it what-so-ever. I also never stated that ships were the number one feature requested. I specifically said both were one of the most highly requested features.
Drama.
Game, set, match.
I'd rather have ships, but @Telaan is killing you in this argument.
He called me an e-bully LOL. He keeps proving my point for me. Look at how worked up he got over me stating a valid opinion.
I have been in MANY online guilds/clans/whatever in MANY games and speak from experience. Guilds start fun, then come the RULES by the LEADER. Elections, debates, drama.
We already HAVE guilds, I was invited 3 times yesterday alone.
Guilds can do tracking without a game update.
Biggest reason ships come before guilds: they can SELL ships.
No one called you an e-bully.... But you have repeatedly used e-bullying as a justification of why guilds shouldn't exist. Your reading comprehension is either off or you're purposely misinterpreting my posts to continue trolling. That's also the worst excuse I've seen yet against guilds. I'm sorry you've had such negative experiences with guilds; many more have had vastly positive experiences. If you can't think of ways that CG can capitalize on guilds...well I don't know what to say..."ioniancat21;256062" wrote:
@Timitock is joking with you clearly about guilds being trouble. I recall seeing a post from him asking for Guilds in fact....
Clearly he's not.
About SWGOH General Discussion
Discuss and share your feedback on Star Wars: Galaxy of Heroes with fellow players.81,196 PostsLatest Activity: 26 minutes ago
Community Highlights
- CG_Meathead3 months ago
Capital Games Team
- CG_Meathead2 years ago
Capital Games Team
Recent Discussions
- 24 minutes ago
- 30 minutes ago
- 39 minutes ago
- 42 minutes ago