There definitely needs to be some standard as to how Rankings are determined in raids, I mean how is it when over half my guild can solo and i have a Higher GP and finish first that i get ranked 3rd, 8th, 5th, 11th, etc..its really a smack in the face after pushing so hard to build my collection of toons to have it really not mean anything when you solo and rank right above the guy with 0 damage who missed the raid completely because its just a random lottery. Ranking ties should be determined by who finishes 1st and/or GP. This along with a new additional raid needs to be addressed as priority and I guarantee that you will be hard pressed to find anyone who disagrees, speaking for the entire swgoh community on this one. Mickey Mic drop*Like this.

Who finishes first just encourages people to break raid rules, so I am very very very much against that.And GP means that the same person wins each time, which is exactly what the randomization fixed, so I am very much against that too.I am perfectly fine with randomization. So, no, you are not speaking for "the entire swgoh community."

I bet when you are no longer top 3 gp in your guild you will then complain about why ties in raid shouldn’t be determined by amount of gp someone has and it should be broken by some other random variable you can find to make you top 3 again. Basically if you are not ranked high, it’s not fair to you.

Random is fine. It's much better than it was before and is better than by GP. There are ways that would be better than random but I would put a this type of change pretty far down my improvement request list.

I dislike all of your suggestions.Whoever finishes first would encourage people to hurry up and down the raid before anyone else gets to go... this is a group raid meant to power up your whole guild.Going by GP means the guy who is the farthest along (and hence needs the gear the least) would always get the top rewards... even if he's 7*ed his Han and others in the guild haven't.The random rank assignment in ties is the best solution for guilds as a group. Everyone was very happy when they switched it to this instead of by player id like it used to be so you definitely represent a minor portion of the swgoh community. The majority applauded when it became this way.

"wrekincruw;c-1417996" wrote:"Liath;c-1417975" wrote:Who finishes first just encourages people to break raid rules, so I am very very very much against that.And GP means that the same person wins each time, which is exactly what the randomization fixed, so I am very much against that too.I am perfectly fine with randomization. So, no, you are not speaking for "the entire swgoh community."Your probably only first due to randomness with that type of talk because anyone who finishes first or builds their Toons to a higher level will not agree with that at all dude, what sense does it make that I develop my characters and Toons to be last when you schmooze by due to a random 0101 . No thanks you work hard and develop your gameplay like everyone else, and if your guild mates are so low-life that they cheat that readily you need to find a new guild bud.Sorry, but you are very wrong. The community has already spoken on this issue... they like it random better.

Rancor Ranking Spankings | EA Forums

wrekincruw
7 years ago
"Woodroward;c-1417995" wrote:
I dislike all of your suggestions.

Whoever finishes first would encourage people to hurry up and down the raid before anyone else gets to go... this is a group raid meant to power up your whole guild.

Going by GP means the guy who is the farthest along (and hence needs the gear the least) would always get the top rewards... even if he's 7*ed his Han and others in the guild haven't.

The random rank assignment in ties is the best solution for guilds as a group. Everyone was very happy when they switched it to this instead of by player id like it used to be so you definitely represent a minor portion of the swgoh community. The majority applauded when it became this way.

No we approved a lesser evil when they switched, and also your guild should have 0 damage rule to ensure weaker mates get rewards so that whole argument about beating Rancor quickly is invalid because Rancor only last for 15 minutes in any Guild that has multiple solo players
wrekincruw
7 years ago
"Woodroward;c-1418006" wrote:
"wrekincruw;c-1418002" wrote:
"Vorgen;c-1417981" wrote:
I bet when you are no longer top 3 gp in your guild you will then **** about why ties in raid shouldn’t be determined by amount of gp someone has and it should be broken by some other random variable you can find to make you top 3 again. Basically if you are not ranked high, it’s not fair to you.

My point is is that I develop my character more than others so why should I be rewarded less? that makes absolutely no sense work harder for Less that is the logic that you guys are saying to me right now, smh seriously think some of you just like to respond for ships and giggles

So you somehow think you are more entitled to rewards than people who did the exact same amount of damage as you?

...ok

The only reason why it's the same amount of Damages because there's a cap on it also that is why It should be determined by who finishes first or GP when it is the same damage there's no entitlement anywhere where do you get that from? I built my Toons I fought hard I'm carrying the weaker of members who cannot solo so why shouldn't I be rewarded? what sense does that make. If you have a job and you work at the end of the week when you go collect your check is that entitlement or is that what you earn from your hard work think about it
wrekincruw
7 years ago
"Liath;c-1418004" wrote:
"wrekincruw;c-1417996" wrote:
"Liath;c-1417975" wrote:
Who finishes first just encourages people to break raid rules, so I am very very very much against that.

And GP means that the same person wins each time, which is exactly what the randomization fixed, so I am very much against that too.

I am perfectly fine with randomization. So, no, you are not speaking for "the entire swgoh community."

Your probably only first due to randomness with that type of talk because anyone who finishes first or builds their Toons to a higher level will not agree with that at all dude, what sense does it make that I develop my characters and Toons to be last when you schmooze by due to a random 0101 . No thanks you work hard and develop your gameplay like everyone else, and if your guild mates are so low-life that they cheat that readily you need to find a new guild bud.

Did you notice how everyone who has posted on this thread so far has agreed with me and none of them have agreed with you? But no, go ahead and continue thinking it's just me.

Is just you the guys schmooze off of the stronger players to get rewards and build your characters up, because you haven't put in the real work you guys are the sponges in your guilds I bet that's why you would hate for it to be built off of Merit of your own actions
wrekincruw
7 years ago
"Vorgen;c-1418013" wrote:
Raids require tickets to launch and whether you have 4mil gp or 400 thousand gp, both of you can only earn a max of 600 per day so those two contributed equally to the launch of a raid and thus should deserve equal chance at earning loot should both score the same in raid.

Someone as selfish as you clearly doesn't understand the concept of a guild.

So using that logic even a guy who can't finish the raid by himself long as he contributes 600 he should get the same exact award because you would not be able to do it without him does that make sense no
vorgen321
7 years ago
"wrekincruw;c-1418017" wrote:
"Vorgen;c-1418013" wrote:
Raids require tickets to launch and whether you have 4mil gp or 400 thousand gp, both of you can only earn a max of 600 per day so those two contributed equally to the launch of a raid and thus should deserve equal chance at earning loot should both score the same in raid.

Someone as selfish as you clearly doesn't understand the concept of a guild.

So using that logic even a guy who can't finish the raid by himself long as he contributes 600 he should get the same exact award because you would not be able to do it without him does that make sense no

Read it more carefully. I said people who score the same so either both finished the raid by themselves or neither did. So yeah, they deserve equal chance at loot.
ARougeRogue
7 years ago
I finished my first solo with G8 characters... Now I toss in CLS and press Auto, as does several others in my guild. To be honest, I'd rather all rewards down the line just be equalized like TB and stop with pushing for competition because it isn't doing anything but encouraging foul play (pre-loading, "accidentally damaging during the 0 hour", etc).

"Oh but that will make it so people in your guild won't work on teams for the raid and will just expect to be carried!" You say? Well, news flash, anyone who is okay with being carried is probably already being carried.
tvsfrink
7 years ago
Everyone is right in this thread except for one person.
manderthegreat
7 years ago
Jumping on the “OP” is wrong train...
Griffingargoyle
7 years ago
"Huatimus;c-1418050" wrote:
"manderthegreat1;c-1418041" wrote:
Jumping on the “OP” is wrong train...

Where can I buy that ticket?

I have an extra one.
Waquira
7 years ago
"wrekincruw;c-1418016" wrote:
"Liath;c-1418004" wrote:
"wrekincruw;c-1417996" wrote:
"Liath;c-1417975" wrote:
Who finishes first just encourages people to break raid rules, so I am very very very much against that.

And GP means that the same person wins each time, which is exactly what the randomization fixed, so I am very much against that too.

I am perfectly fine with randomization. So, no, you are not speaking for "the entire swgoh community."

Your probably only first due to randomness with that type of talk because anyone who finishes first or builds their Toons to a higher level will not agree with that at all dude, what sense does it make that I develop my characters and Toons to be last when you schmooze by due to a random 0101 . No thanks you work hard and develop your gameplay like everyone else, and if your guild mates are so low-life that they cheat that readily you need to find a new guild bud.

Did you notice how everyone who has posted on this thread so far has agreed with me and none of them have agreed with you? But no, go ahead and continue thinking it's just me.

Is just you the guys schmooze off of the stronger players to get rewards and build your characters up, because you haven't put in the real work you guys are the sponges in your guilds I bet that's why you would hate for it to be built off of Merit of your own actions

ROFL!