It’s all my low damage deal dealing Ewok team HASSSS! It makes them even more unviable, and Logray becomes essentially useless.

Immunity means can't happen.Padme's team auto resists all buffs when they have protection up. Irresistible debuffs still go through.Padme is immune to fear. Fear is irresistible. Immunity means the thing means nothing to you, period.

"MAO408;c-1944503" wrote:"Woodroward;c-1944475" wrote:"MAO408;c-1944453" wrote:"Woodroward;c-1944409" wrote:Immunity means can't happen.Padme's team auto resists all buffs when they have protection up. Irresistible debuffs still go through.Padme is immune to fear. Fear is irresistible. Immunity means the thing means nothing to you, period.Yes I understand, but when 1 buff makes another buff that guarantees a critical hit useless, then that's 1 buff that's more unbalanced, PERIOD. It's not even a big deal having my 100% natural grit chance on Ewok scout not mean he gets a critical, but instead of advantage doubling that criteria at the very least, it's a useless buff on an even more useless team; as an effect. Let's say you had a real life buff that guaranteed you'd melt the enemy's bones on your next attack, but then you were forced to attack a blob monster.It would not matter. Same kind of scenario here.Now if advantage got used up even though you hit someone with crit immunity, I'd agree that's messed up (unless it was because the timer was up on the buff).Just like they changed foresight so it didn't get used up if they were hit with an unavoidable attack.Once again, good analogy, but it’s a stretch to say that a buff, just like another buff, would change the toon so drastically to where they become another entity (blob monster). Let’s have it to where it cancels that crit ratio and your base crit chance determines a crit, or have the buff cancel one another-out (dispel).Crit immunity is way too powerful without another check that’s supposed to help with crits, Advantage. Not all buffs are created equal. Look at Millenium Falcon's buff in Fleet.Advantage is actually supposed to be a weaker buff. It's a one time use offense buff. Crit immunity is supposed to be a strong buff. Why should a weak buff cancel out a strong buff?Offense buffs are weaker than defense buffs in general because they (typically) have less opportunity for use.Thanks on the analogies. I actually chanced it right as you posted to make it more appropriate to a battle scenario.

"Ravenclaws;c-1944654" wrote:Advantage adds 200% crit chance, crit immunity adds 999999% crit avoidance. No more needs to be said.

No.The only issue to resolve Advantage being a useless buff is to allow the attacker to have either +25% offence or +25% potency for that hit. If your characters have good enough critical hit chance, it's obviously useless.

I actually agree, mainly because advantage is such an underpowered buff now that crit chances have become so high. We see in several instances that we can mod characters to 100% crit chance.

Who thinks that Advantage should cancel out Critical Hit Immunity?

25 Replies

AyyOkage
New Traveler
6 years ago
"Woodroward;c-1944409" wrote:
Immunity means can't happen.

Padme's team auto resists all buffs when they have protection up. Irresistible debuffs still go through.

Padme is immune to fear. Fear is irresistible.

Immunity means the thing means nothing to you, period.

I understand, but for the Padme example... it clearly states in her Unique that she’s immune. My argument is on the basis of Critical hit immunity being to good for a normal and non-unique buff. Another buff (Advantage), should be able to cancel it out, or too take it a step further, remove it instead.

Your comparison is different, but thanks for the opinion.
RavenClaws86
6 years ago
Advantage adds 200% crit chance, crit immunity adds 999999% crit avoidance.

No more needs to be said.
CCyrilS
6 years ago
"Ravenclaws;c-1944654" wrote:
Advantage adds 200% crit chance, crit immunity adds 999999% crit avoidance.

No more needs to be said.
AyyOkage
New Traveler
6 years ago
"Ravenclaws;c-1944654" wrote:
Advantage adds 200% crit chance, crit immunity adds 999999% crit avoidance.

No more needs to be said.

Crit Immunity should be exclusive to Fleet battles, enough said.

It should be changed to only an immunity to 1 critical attack... or it should provide 100% critical avoidance while the buff is present, like Tenacity up. That way advantage would at least cancel it out for a hit, although I think it should be dispelled, and then my base 97% critical hit ratio on my low damage dealing Ewok, wouldn't go to waste.
AyyOkage
New Traveler
6 years ago
"CCyrilS;c-1944683" wrote:
"Ravenclaws;c-1944654" wrote:
Advantage adds 200% crit chance, crit immunity adds 999999% crit avoidance.

No more needs to be said.

Critical Hit Immunity is too powerful to be a non-unique buff...it's not chance based... it just makes the rng of getting a critical hit with my 100% base toon ration + my advantage + my critical chance up + my critical damage up + not matter or even be acknowledged. It automatically turns whoever so wields that buff into a mini raid boss. C'mon man, essentially 3 different critical based buffs, all useless... when my character already has a raw critical chance of 97%???

"So it's treason, then?"

- How I feel when I have all those critical chance buffs, wasting precious set-up turns, just to be critical immunitied on...
tvsfrink
6 years ago
"MAO408;c-1944766" wrote:
"Ravenclaws;c-1944654" wrote:
Advantage adds 200% crit chance, crit immunity adds 999999% crit avoidance.

No more needs to be said.

Crit Immunity should be exclusive to Fleet battles, enough said.

What.
Nikoms565
6 years ago
"MAO408;c-1944766" wrote:
"Ravenclaws;c-1944654" wrote:
Advantage adds 200% crit chance, crit immunity adds 999999% crit avoidance.

No more needs to be said.

Crit Immunity should be exclusive to Fleet battles, enough said.

It should be changed to only an immunity to 1 critical attack... or it should provide 100% critical avoidance while the buff is present, like Tenacity up. That way advantage would at least cancel it out for a hit, although I think it should be dispelled, and then my base 97% critical hit ratio on my low damage dealing Ewok, wouldn't go to waste.

This is all just about Ewoks? So sad.

Two things:

1) Immunity means "can't happen", so no.

2) Ewoks don't need more damage. With their kits and synergies they take like 37 turns before anyone else gets to go again. (Please note: No actual math was used during this example)
almightywood
6 years ago
I remember taking on GK +Zarriss with droids and then JTR.
Pain in the butt. If GK didn't give Zarriss Crit immunity I could never have killed her or anyone else. (kept GK from taunting and her from healing).

So there are situations where having crit immunity on the enemy actually benefits you.
AntiFunn
6 years ago
No.

The only issue to resolve Advantage being a useless buff is to allow the attacker to have either +25% offence or +25% potency for that hit.
If your characters have good enough critical hit chance, it's obviously useless.
AyyOkage
New Traveler
6 years ago
"TVF;c-1944847" wrote:
"MAO408;c-1944766" wrote:
"Ravenclaws;c-1944654" wrote:
Advantage adds 200% crit chance, crit immunity adds 999999% crit avoidance.

No more needs to be said.

Crit Immunity should be exclusive to Fleet battles, enough said.

What.

It used to be.