Okay. Let's talk improving the aliens...
Aliens are probably one of the most iconic occults in The Sims series, but next to the likes of vampires, fairies, mermaids and so on they have felt underwhelming for a while. There have also been issues with undesirable autonomous actions from alien Sims, and controversies with abduction and alien pregnancy mechanics.
Any time I see discussion on how to improve aliens it seems like things get disjointed and even heated. So I've gathered a lot of stuff here in one place and I hope we can have a proper chat about how to give alien Sims some love!
Give Aliens a Perk Tree
(Disclaimer: I haven't played with and don't have access to occults that have a perk tree, so I have no frame of reference for how this typically works. My ideas may not align with existing perk tree mechanics, so thoughts from anyone experienced in this area are appreciated!)
Aliens are one of the only Occults to not have a Perk Tree. Updating them to have one would be a great way to give alien Sims new and improved powers. They could learn to positively or negatively impact the emotional states of other Sims. Perhaps gain mind control abilities similar to those found on the SimRay, or be able to protect non-alien household members from abduction without the use of the Satellite Dish.
Improve Brain Power with a system that determines how many powers they can use consecutively before getting drained. More impactful powers such as preventing abductions would use a lot of BP. Resurrecting dead alien collectibles, erasing memories or transmuting elements would use a fair bit, but not nearly as much. Analysing personalities and empathising with other Sims would use very little.
Changing in and out of their disguise could also be tied to BP, perhaps comparable to powers such as Transmute in terms of how much is needed. This would give aliens a need to be cautious about when they choose to switch between their appearances, if they don't want to risk being seen by Sims who aren't already aware.
Brain Power could regenerate over time. If completely drained, apply the current Tense moodlet for low BP. This could then slow, or entirely stop BP regeneration until the moodlet fades.
On the subject of alien abilities...
The Problem of Autonomous Memory Erase
This seriously needs addressing. Simmers playing with aliens are finding they will sometimes completely destroy perfectly fine relationships. Close friendships ruined. Marriages between alien and non-alien Sims broken, as well as other familial relationships.
It makes no sense for alien Sims to want to erase the memories of people they are close to. Those are people they should be able to trust. They know the truth and still care for them. Wanting to erase the memories of Sims that an alien has a bad relationship with (disliked or worse) makes sense, but friends and family should never be the target of autonomous Memory Erase.
If directed to Memory Erase Sims they have a good relationship with, the alien should get a negative moodlet from it depending on the type of relationship. They could be sad about losing a friend. Embarrassed with themselves for "accidentally" wiping their memory. Angry if there was something else happening that might make erasing memories desirable, like catching a spouse or romantic partner cheating beforehand.
If you've seen my posts about Quincy you'll understand how confusing and heart breaking this side to playing alien Sims is for me. It's so wrong seeing this absolute sweetheart suddenly decide he's going to sabotage his friendships for no good reason!😭 I am begging for this to be fixed. It is so stupid.
Abductions and Alien Pregnancies
Hoo boy... This one always seems to cause controversy whenever it's bought up, but I'm doing it anyway. There has got to be a way to improve this mechanic for all playstyle preferences, and hopefully I've come up with some ideas that work for everyone. Options that you can use or ignore, depending on what you want out of alien gameplay.
Let's keep this part of the discussion civil and constructive please! I want to see more ideas on how to improve things in a way that works for every playstyle, not arguments and telling people they're playing wrong.
Okay. To start off, when it comes to dealing with this side of alien gameplay I see three basic groups:
The first is not only happy for abductions and pregnancies to happen, they often want it. They enjoy pretty much everything about alien gameplay and are fine with things the way they are. Except for the lack of an Alien Perk Tree. Yeah, they would love that to finally happen.
The second is a kind of middle ground. This is where I sit. I'm generally cool with alien gameplay, and I want to explore more of it, but I have households I do NOT want involved in pregnancies. I feel the in-game options we have to prevent that are not robust enough for this style of gameplay. I'm currently using a mod that stops it entirely, and I would LOVE to be able to remove it. And I want an Alien Perk Tree.
The third wants as little to do with alien gameplay as possible, for whatever reason. They may enjoy the rest of Get to Work, but are fed up of having their Sims abducted. Some Simmers in this group may feel there is a problematic element to alien pregnancies that makes them uncomfortable engaging with the mechanic, and potentially WANT to play with it if not for the perceived issues.
On that last point...
The Perception of Assault
While there are various reasons for Simmers to not want to deal with alien pregnancies (for me it simply doesn't fit in with the story of some of my households), one that sometimes comes up is players seeing the way they are handled as problematic.
Your abducted male Sim returns, seemingly unharmed except for one little detail. Are they... Pregnant? 😱 Given how people usually end up this way some Simmers jump to the conclusion that their Sim has been subjected to non-consensual WooHoo/Try for Baby.
I get why this makes the mechanic feel unsettling for some, but they also have the wrong idea. What's more likely? A male Sim gets pregnant via WooHoo with a different species, or they are subjected to a surgical procedure that allows someone who doesn't have the relevant anatomy to carry an alien baby? I have come across discussions that suggest there is in-game lore somewhere in the series that either supports this, or describes another method via which male Sims become pregnant without WooHoo involved. I'd be interested to see exactly what any verifiable in-game lore says about this, if anyone can point to it!
Still, this doesn't entirely resolve the elements which bother some players. Being subjected to an unwanted pregnancy isn't great either, leaving some players still troubled by the matter of bodily autonomy. If your Sim gets pregnant via abduction there's nothing they can do but ride it out and send the baby back to its home world if its not wanted.
I'm also seeing a double standard here. Haha male pregnancy funny! Sure, but some players don't find it amusing when it's forced. And why do only male Sims get alien pregnancies via abduction? Yeah, it's a classic sci-fi trope, but I don't doubt concern about the devs facing backlash if they allowed female Sims the same experience plays at least some part in why they can't get pregnant via abduction.
Also, if you're playing a WxW household, doesn't it suck that you CAN'T have an alien baby this way, if it's something you want? Come on. Give lesbian households a chance live out their alien baby raising dreams!
Current Solutions
If you want to avoid abductions and/or alien pregnancy, this is what you can do now.
Build the Satellite Dish. Gameplay wise, your best option right now is to enter the Scientist career path and progress until you can build the Satellite Dish. This has a "Prevent Abductions" setting, along with some other fun things. But it's on a timer and you have to reactivate it after a while. It also has to be placed on your lot, which may be undesirable for some. And you're still facing the risk of abduction while you work towards this, unless you're willing to cheat to unlock it.
Avoid actions which increase the chance of abduction. Your chances aren't zero, but yes, there are things your Sim can do which makes abduction more likely. Some of these are easily avoided, if you're aware of them. Others, not so much. Discovered another Sim is an alien in disguise? Oops! Abduction chance just increased. Also, the Scientist career path impacts this, so while you're working towards getting one of the few things that can stop abductions, your Sim is more likely to get yoinked upwards one night.
"resetsim" to stop "Investigate Strange Light" action. If you catch a Sim with "Investigate Strange Light" queued up, the "resetsim" cheat cancels all current actions for the reset Sim and stops this. It requires the player to be vigilant during times abductions can happen though. Really tricky if you have lots of Sims in a household! It's also easily missed as your Sims are likely to be asleep when the lights arrive and time is sped up.
Install mods. Finally, there are mods which give more control over abductions and pregnancies. You're then hoping that the mod will still work when the game gets official patches. If it doesn't, better hope the mod creator is on top of that! And console players? Sorry, but you're out of luck here. 🤷♀️
Proposed Fixes and Additional Improvements
Here is everything I've come up with so far to try and address the concerns with abductions and alien pregnancies. These should allow all Simmers to cater things to their playstyle preference, whether you want to experience the mechanics fully, keep specific Sims or households out of it, or want to minimise the impact of alien gameplay on your save entirely while still enjoying the rest of GtW.
I've also included a few other suggestions, just for adding some fun extra details and currently missing elements.
Improve the satellite dish. Instead of having to reactivate it after a period, allow it to continue preventing abductions until the player turns it off, activates a different feature, or the dish breaks and needs repair. It could be added as an upgrade option at the Invention Constructor rather than something the dish has from the start.
Cancel "Investigate Strange Lights" activity in the queue. Some players claim this can be done already, but apparently that's not the case. At the very least it has never worked for me. I've only ever been able to stop it with the "resetsim" cheat.
Strange lights alarm system. Add a new alarm type that can warn Sims of the presence of strange lights so that they keep away. It could be a small, security camera that can be built at the Invention Constructor and would link up the the existing burglar alarm, as long as one is placed nearby. Make it so that it can be placed as either wall mounted or floor standing.
The alarm for strange lights should have its own sound so players don't confuse strange lights alerts with being robbed! This can also act as an alert for the player, who can direct their Sims to ignore it and investigate the lights anyway.
"Can this Sim carry an alien baby?" CAS setting. Add a CAS setting that allows players to set whether or not a Sim is able to carry an alien baby, giving players more control over Sims they do not want involved in this mechanic. They can still get abducted. It just means players don't have to worry about unwanted pregnancies.
A procedure to prevent alien pregnancy. Another option could be sending Sims to the hospital or lab for a procedure that prevents alien pregnancies if abducted (should be 100% effective. This is aimed at players who don't want pregnancy for some Sims). There could also be an option for undoing this.
Aliens offer impregnation. Have there be a chance for aliens to ask the abducted Sim if they would carry an alien baby rather than force pregnancy on them. This would give players a choice, resolving the issue of some finding the mechanic problematic. Add dialogue with the aliens flattering their target Sim about how they'd be a perfect host or some other persuasion, with options to agree or disagree. It would also feel like a more realistic interaction with what is supposed to be an intelligent species. Wouldn't a willing carrier be more desirable to ensure their offspring's safety? 🤔
New moodlets tied to accepting or refusing alien baby. These could be based on traits, current career paths, and other aspects of the Sim's personality and life which might impact how they feel about having an alien baby. Adventurous Sims would likely be excited about the experience. Child hating Sims would absolutely be questioning their decision if they accept! Family-Oriented Sims and those on the Scientist career path may regret turning down the opportunity.
Allow female Sims to become pregnant via abduction. If pregnancy is now something that can be accepted or refused, there's no reason to leave the ladies out of the fun!
Counterpart to "Known Alien" relationship marker. Currently, only non-alien Sims have a marker for discovering Sims they know are aliens. Aliens who have been discovered don't have a similar marker on their friends' profiles. The only way to check whether or not another Sim knows is to play as that Sim and check the alien's profile. We need aliens to keep track of who has discovered them on their side too.
Overall, I love the aliens in The Sims 4. I really want them to get the care and attention they deserve, and improvements that might make more players want to engage with them. Especially for Simmers who have concerns about the way alien pregnancies are handled. Aliens in the game are generally portrayed as friendly beings (individuals with Mean or Evil traits aside, and even they aren't truly malevolent), and it's a shame that certain mechanics are souring how some Simmers view them.