Ideas

BCFCRICH's avatar
BCFCRICH
Seasoned Observer
10 days ago

When's the Next Title Update to Fix the Bugs Caused by Fixing the Bugs? 😂

Since the v1.2.0 title update, all I seem to be reading on here is people saying, "It's still there", "Still not fixed", or reporting entirely new bugs that weren't there before.

So, genuine question, EA. What exactly have you managed to fix without breaking something else in the process?

I've personally reported numerous bugs on this forum, some repeatedly, and even gone as far as sending private messages directly to EA staff. Not only have these issues not been fixed, but the messages haven't even been acknowledged, let alone answered.

What's the point of having an official bugs forum if the people taking the time to report these issues are seemingly being ignored? We're effectively doing the quality testing for you, pointing out problems that should have been picked up long before release, yet getting absolutely nowhere.

Every title update seems to need another title update to fix whatever the previous title update broke, while bugs that have been reported for weeks, months, and in some cases years are still there.

At this rate, you might actually get FC 27 working properly just in time for the release of FC 28.

5 Comments

  • BCFCRICH's avatar
    BCFCRICH
    Seasoned Observer
    10 days ago

    I completely agree with you, and unfortunately, it seems to be getting worse and worse every year.

    I only play Career Mode. That's the whole reason I buy this game, yet every single year it's the same old issues, with a whole load of new ones thrown in for good measure.

    What EA seem very good at doing is introducing some shiny new feature, making a big song and dance about it, showing off all the polished animations and promotional footage, and hoping that's enough to convince everyone they've made massive improvements. This year we've got "The Grounds", which I haven't even looked at once. I couldn't care less about it. I just want the actual football game to work properly!

    But we all know where EA's biggest priority lies. Ultimate Team. It's a constant revenue stream for them, so everything else seemingly takes a back seat.

    Meanwhile, in Career Mode, we've got tactics that don't work as intended, players not taking up their assigned positions, random officials walking across the pitch during matches, footballs floating in mid-air, substitutes not appearing in the order you've selected, away supporters wearing their team's away kit and even goalkeeper jerseys, social media stories that are complete nonsense and make absolutely no sense whatsoever, audio that's out of sync, supporters displaying the wrong flags or no flags at all, and the list goes on and on.

    Then EA release a 6GB title update, and what happens? None of those issues appear to have been addressed. In fact, all I've seen since v1.2.0 is people reporting that the same bugs are still there, which they are, along with new problems that weren't there before.

    So what exactly are they testing before releasing these updates?

    My son and I develop our own games. Obviously, we're not producing anything on the scale of FC 27, but we spend hours every single day testing what we've built, running through different scenarios, checking that changes work properly and, importantly, making sure those changes haven't broken something else.

    When we can't work something out, we use AI to help examine the code, identify potential problems and suggest solutions. But we still have to test those solutions ourselves. That's the whole point!

    Which makes me wonder what on earth is happening at EA. As someone else pointed out, you genuinely have to question whether they still have the experienced programmers and QA people needed to maintain something of this complexity. Because from the outside, it increasingly looks like somebody is bodging one problem, creating another three in the process, and releasing the update anyway.

    EA even recruit volunteers to playtest the game before release. What actually happens to all their feedback? Do they listen to those people? Do they act on the problems they identify? Or is it much like this forum, where people spend their own time reporting issues, providing evidence and explaining exactly how to reproduce them, only to be completely ignored?

    I've personally reported numerous bugs, some repeatedly, and even sent private messages directly to EA staff on this forum. Not one acknowledgement, let alone an actual response.

    I've also regularly seen EA state that they aren't making changes to gameplay. Why? Is it because they genuinely believe everything is working as intended, or because they don't know how to fix certain things without breaking something else?

    I've been buying FIFA, and now FC, for well over 20 years. I've always bought it on release day, without fail. My wife and son have been telling me for the last few years that I'm mad. They always say, "Why do you keep buying it on release when you know it's going to be broken and won't be working properly until Christmas?"

    And you know what? They're absolutely right.

    But every year I give EA the benefit of the doubt. Every year I think surely this time they'll have addressed the long-standing problems, learned from previous mistakes and delivered something that actually works properly from day one.

    Yet here we are again.

    I would genuinely rather wait until Christmas for a finished, properly tested football game than pay full price in September for something that feels like it's still going through development.

    What makes it worse is the complete lack of communication. After more than two decades of supporting this franchise and spending my hard-earned money on it, EA can't even be bothered to acknowledge an email or private message about issues with their own product. It's disgraceful, and frankly an insult to the loyal customers who have supported them year after year.

    It's also incredibly frustrating watching them seemingly cherry-pick which problems they want to address while ignoring others that have been reported repeatedly for months, sometimes years.

    What exactly is the point of having a bug-reporting forum if nobody appears to be listening?

    I don't expect perfection. No game of this size is ever going to be completely bug-free. But I do expect basic functionality to work, proper testing before updates are released, and some level of communication and accountability when customers report problems.

    It's genuinely sad because I've loved this franchise for decades. Football games have always been something I've enjoyed, and Career Mode is the reason I keep coming back.

    But there's only so far you can push loyal customers before they eventually have enough.

    I've defended EA and given them the benefit of the doubt for years, but I'm rapidly reaching that point myself.

     

    The sad thing is, I don't actually want to stop buying this game. I just want EA to give me a reason to carry on buying it.

  • Amazing isn't it. I work for a software company as a QA. Admittedly not as complex of a software as a video game but the same logic should apply to bug fixes. 

    It's increasingly looking to me like EA are not passing anything through even basic testing or regression testing by a human, instead leaning on AI to just review the code and cutting back on actual human QA (something rampant in software since AI became a major thing).

    I mainly suspect this as there is no way any QA team worth their money could miss the fact these tactics bugs they claim to have fixed are actually nowhere near fixed. How hard is it to set up a tactic on the fix build, then set up another where players are moved into irregular positions, then re-assign them to a different position, save, go into a game, switch to the second tactic and check the players are in the positions where you saved them 🫠

    I was going to keep EAFC installed and dip in now and then around the time my supported team plays to get a football fix if they had managed to sort many of the frustrations out while mainly switching to the other game released next week. But having seen that game is 210GB I might just uninstall EAFC to save space on my console and give the rest of this  EAFC cycle a miss. 

    EA won't care, they have my money now and I have in recent editions not been someone who does alot of secondary spending in the game so it'll be an awww well thanks for the custom, cya loser!  

  • blue166's avatar
    blue166
    Seasoned Ace
    10 days ago

    This lot don't know what they are doing. 

    EA has had to of lost a lot of talented people and replaced them with poor design and development team. That isn't me being rude it's me judging by the complete mess and negligence from this bunch.

    I have been swindled out of £70 for this game. I only play Seasons mode and EA has no respect for us players. 

    🤡