Re: Thick girl got skinny, why?
I have to agree - the first sim I made in my playsave, while not very good in CAS (still am not) was so pretty to me, all round and luscious. But I gave them the career of broker, and they ate a lot of fruitcake, that horrid thing (kidding, I love it myself), and I tried to combat it with exercise, but they just lost the spark and got all toned, just like every other sim that goes to the gym.
I do think it is cute with a dynamic feature like that, having the sims gain and loose weight through gameplay; I just wish it was a little reworked. For instance, I find gyms uninteresting, so I would wish them to loose weight through other means, playing chess, programming, dancing, woohooing; and the amount they gain in weight just for having a couple of fat meals is remarkable, and perhaps a little excessive.