Should I (or players like me) quit online multiplayer games?

@Axs5626Sxa5001You feel punished for being among people of your own skill, while others feel punished for being put in lobbies with people that are either too high or too low for their skill expectations. This is proof that everyone feels bad, even though the matchmaking does try to make things good for everyone by not being too strict or too loose.

The solution is probably coming soon: custom servers. You will be able to play with your friends, your club members, streamers, etc. and also get more moments to chill and play the game differently, with your own set of rules.

@Axs5626Sxa5001

"why does my overall gaming experience matter less than someone else’s BECAUSE I am in a higher skill group?"
Very true. The tyranny of the majority over the minority --it feels discriminating for sure.
But you also have your answer.
"I understand that gaming publishers have to cater to the largest player group (casual players) to maximize their profits". That is why.

If you go ahead and quit is entirely up to you. EA would never recommend you quit, but EA would not bother one way or the other IMO. And given that if all top players were to quit it would be a 5% loss at most, I do not see how that would be any significant. The general skill level will receive a hit, and a new skill level with a new pool of 5%-ers will be established and that would be about it. I do not see why top streamers would ever quit though, until they can make an income from it. Or make cash playing in tournaments, cups, etc.

I occasionally watch ALGS matches and find them very boring. It is all calculated and very slow gameplay, except eventually for the final 2 circles where teams have lost their positions to the ring and are forced out of their camping spot.
Ranked is not that much campy, but it is fairly campy too. So IF I were in your position, I would consider quitting because of the campy playstyle higher ranks have, rather than the win ratio. Which are perhaps connected topics (playstyle and win ratio)?

@Axs5626Sxa5001

EDIT: I have the opposite issue. I am constantly paired with players who plainly either refuse to engage in ANY gunfights, or who are totally oblivious of what they are doing. It is a chronic issue that has no solving, and a large impact on the enjoyment of the game.
IMO the lobby does not need to be balanced on the skill side, but the team needs to be somehow more balance. I mean it is ok placing a very strong team in a random lobby. It is not ok placing a very strong player with 2 very weak player, or a very weak player with 2 very strong players.
The way it's now is a lose-lose.

"What I don’t want: I don’t want to play in lobbies filled with low-skilled players. Stomping is boring."

Stomping is boring, but when you play your rank is too hard?
If stomping is boring, and PUBS are boring, and your own rank is too hard, maybe next split you could try and float in diamond? just win a game and throw the next ones to remain in diamond 4.

Also when you say WE ARE ABLE TO GET BACK RELATIVELY QUICKLY after a split, does it mean you play with a team?

If that is the case, just play soloq for a change, I can guarantee you soloq in pubs will open up perspective that from the top you would never imagine existed! (just kidding). But yeah, pubs soloq will be way more random than with a premade.