Left faceoff grip broken

Having an issue at faceoff where if i try to grip the stick left it immediately triggers a draw. Forehand or backhand, even if i pull the stick to 8 or 7 oclock. Does not happen to right hand side at all. Three different controllers, one brand new. Reset console settings, uninstalled and reinstalled game, still it triggers, sometimes two or three times before i can reset to a new motion. Ive played hundreds of games and now i suddenly cant take a faceoff. What is happening?