She's not bad. She has a lot of major issues, though.
For one thing, she's poor on offense. Technically she beats a lot, but with such poor banners that the old counters are still superior.
For another, she seems poor on defense. I say seems, because we've not gotten a full GAC round and barely had TW data from her, and this team is one that is defined by its omicrons. We need GAC and TW data (after bugs are fixed - see my next point) to really know how she'll stack up, but at the moment anything that can ignore taunt (Leia), deal high true damage (JML, Maul), or in general deal high AoE damage or AoE stuns is a massive problem for her, as 3/5 of her team are incredibly weak.
Then there are the bugs... there are many. Some are minor, some are entire parts of her kit that just don't work. In all honesty, this reminds of Leviathan's release and - much love to CG - the quality issues with new releases are an unacceptable problem that we really need to see acknowledged and fixed moving forward.
Finally, she has no PVE tie-in so far. She's so expensive and so seemingly niche that without some dedicated resource event or some PVE mode that requires her use (TB or raid), she's incredibly low priority.
For reference, the bugs that I've noted (and will be reporting in the bugs forum) are:
- Huyang's Special 1 - Auxiliary Grapplers - is not gaining additional attacks from Sabine, General Syndulla, or himself starting the battle with Exile. He *is* gaining an additional attack from Ezra Bridger (Exile) starting with Exile. This looks to be an order of operations issue with Huyang checking for Exile at the start of battle before Ahsoka's lead places Exile onto the rest of her team.
- Huyang isn't granting Jedi Lessons at the start of battle to anyone except Ahsoka Tano. Ezra Bridge (Exile) and Padawan Sabine Wren should both be gaining Jedi Lessons at the start of battle due to his unique (Lightsaber Architect)
- Ezra is coded to gain taunt ignore even though it's not specified in his kit at all.
- Backup Plan from Ezra's Special 1 - Kanan's Legacy - doesn't seem to be working at all, allies with backup plan are dying and not returning.
- Ahsoka's "Deflective Target" isn't working at all. She isn't gaining bonus turns against enemies with Deflective Target, and Deflective Target is never dispelled from enemies.
- Ahsoka's AI is very bad. The AI is often utilizing Reunite, targeting Ahsoka (who gains nothing from this) or targeting an ally without Exile while allies with Exile still exist on the field. This can lead to cases where Ahsoka reaches her ultimate very slowly, or doesn't reach her ultimate at all, and dramatically hinders her defensive viability.
These aren't exhaustive, I'm sure there are others. And the last point, regarding the AI, is more of a balance thing but is incredibly important. There are a lot of finesse things with this team - who to target with Reunite, who to target with Ahsoka's Special 2, who to target with Ezra's Special 1 - that the AI just will never do, and that's OK. But at least hard coding Reunite to prioritize allies with Exile seems like something that can and should be done.
Overall, a bumpy start to Ahsoka. But lots that can hopefully be fixed once CG is back from vacation, no need to get too worked up.