Hey so I randomly got kicked from my guild after contributing to Phase 6 of TB, do they lose all that progression? If not can I please be compensated for this? It’s not really fair.I know what everyone’s thinking, I did something terrible, but I really truly haven’t done anything out of the ordinary, and I don’t know why they kicked me. I don’t want to come crashing down on the world with the hammer of anger, all I want is some kind of reassurance that the world isn’t all evil. If I don’t at least benefit from the TB, then this seems kinda unfair to me.

Unfortunately i dont think you get any rewards from TB :'( Thats an uncool move by your guild, sorry.

But, @CG_SBCrumb or @Kyno if you see this then could you advocate for a fix? I’m sure I’m not the only one, and it would be nice to reassure people that their raid and TB investments are secure.

have you tried asking your guildmates?

"Nihion;c-2058577" wrote:But, @CG_SBCrumb or @Kyno if you see this then could you advocate for a fix? I’m sure I’m not the only one, and it would be nice to reassure people that their raid and TB investments are secure.CG won't compensate you anything for this. It's an issue between players and we'll, it sucks but is the truth. Sorry it happened to you but the best you can do is drop it and keep looking

My guess would be there was probably some rule violation that occurred at some point during the TB that made them decide to kick you, but since members can't participate in TB if they join midway through it a lot of guilds wait until after TB has ended to kick people who don't live up to guild expectations in some form or another so that they don't sell themselves short by parting ways.That being said, guilds will usually still let people collect their rewards before kicking them unless they have committed a very grave offense or maybe even one they've been warned about multiple times.But there are some mean or elitist guilds who don't care at all about those who don't live up to their standards. Not sure which scenario is better for you. Sorry about your luck.

Mean Guild I Guess? | EA Forums

55 Replies

littlemac2014
Seasoned Ace
6 years ago
Unfortunately i dont think you get any rewards from TB :'(

Thats an uncool move by your guild, sorry.
Nihion
6 years ago
Yeah, thanks though. I just found it weird. Oh well. Better luck next guild.
Nihion
6 years ago
But, @CG_SBCrumb or @Kyno if you see this then could you advocate for a fix? I’m sure I’m not the only one, and it would be nice to reassure people that their raid and TB investments are secure.
GifafiTho
6 years ago
have you tried asking your guildmates?
Jeepers4489
New Ace
6 years ago
"Nihion;c-2058577" wrote:
But, @CG_SBCrumb or @Kyno if you see this then could you advocate for a fix? I’m sure I’m not the only one, and it would be nice to reassure people that their raid and TB investments are secure.

CG won't compensate you anything for this. It's an issue between players and we'll, it sucks but is the truth. Sorry it happened to you but the best you can do is drop it and keep looking
almightywood
6 years ago
My guess would be there was probably some rule violation that occurred at some point during the TB that made them decide to kick you, but since members can't participate in TB if they join midway through it a lot of guilds wait until after TB has ended to kick people who don't live up to guild expectations in some form or another so that they don't sell themselves short by parting ways.

That being said, guilds will usually still let people collect their rewards before kicking them unless they have committed a very grave offense or maybe even one they've been warned about multiple times.

But there are some mean or elitist guilds who don't care at all about those who don't live up to their standards.

Not sure which scenario is better for you. Sorry about your luck.
Nihion
6 years ago
I don’t know, I may have brown some rule I wasn’t aware of, but I feel like for the future of the game, there should be some fix to make this fair for everyone. There’s no harm to the guild if I get rewards, and if not then it’s only fair that they don’t deserve my contribution. I spent maybe 4 total hours over 6 days on this and all I get is some TB tokens along the way? It might just be me, but that just doesn’t seem fair.
SupressedNinja6
6 years ago
@Nihion I'm more then happy for you to join my guild? Send me a message on here or in game 552934363
Nihion
6 years ago
"NinjaRaven32;c-2058626" wrote:
@Nihion I'm more then happy for you to join my guild? Send me a message on here or in game 552934363

Thank you!
almightywood
6 years ago
"Nihion;c-2058624" wrote:
I don’t know, I may have brown some rule I wasn’t aware of, but I feel like for the future of the game, there should be some fix to make this fair for everyone. There’s no harm to the guild if I get rewards, and if not then it’s only fair that they don’t deserve my contribution. I spent maybe 4 total hours over 6 days on this and all I get is some TB tokens along the way? It might just be me, but that just doesn’t seem fair.

It's definitely a kick in the keister. It's hard to come up with an adequate solution though. Like it could go the other way too. If someone sits in a guild for the whole tb and only puts 1 person in 1 platoon day 1 then a lot of people would say it's very fair to kick that person before rewards since they didn't contribute enough to earn the rewards. If people get rewards no matter what then people lose the option to deny people who are just leeching.

When it comes down to it, a guild is all about teamwork. Whatever the case may be for your dismissal, I'd say that you all weren't really a team if they kicked you like that. I'd just say chalk it up as finding out where you don't belong en route to where you do.