Let try to keep this on topic.
I removed a few references to any intent or nefarious activity.
As others have said in other posts on the topic, let's not focus on how to guilds get to equal active GP but different numbers of players.
Once they are there:
-do you think its fair?
- should it change?
- what's wrong with it?
- ..... and so on
Let's stay on the topic of matchmaking in this scenario, not how we reached the initial point, as not everyone plays the same way, or has any intention on being mismatched