The definition of a Guild: an association of people for mutual aid or the pursuit of a common goal.This works in part in SWGoH, but only in terms of collecting Raid tickets. The mutual aid/goal then quickly deteriorates to a rat race and every man for themselves to the top 10.Suggested Improvements:1. Pool Daily Guild Activities.For example; if you reach Tier IV by spending 25,000 energy this is then converterted 1:1 in to Guild Coins and divided equally between all guild members. (500 coins each using this example)2. Even Out Raid RewardsPlaces 1-3 = Red Rewards.Places 4-30 = Gold Rewards.Places 31-50 = Purple Rewards.In addition the successful completion of a raid should award a large payout of Guild Coins that is divided evenly to all guild members.3. Add a Guild Deposit Centre.This would be a function which allows guild members to deposit purple gear and rewards the guild for completing a set number of deposits. For example... let's say 1250 stun cuffs is the target amount, once complete all guild members would receive a set of fully crafted cuffs. Double deposit weekends could even feature as an event?4. Reward Ally Points for using Guild ExchangeThe ally rewards stop after 1000 donations. They should continue in line with the amount of donations you've made.

Don't agree with equal distribution on dailies. If I'm saving up energy, timing my collection of my free energy, and buying 5 refreshes to get the top spot, I don't want to get the same rewards as the guy who isn't even bothering with the activity

To be fair, valid point.What you're describing here, kind of sums up my gripe with the whole notion of SWGoH's guild system. A supposed 'guild activity', which requires you to internally compete for the top spot. It's really bad design, I mean I could understand if it was a guild vs guild challenge.

GUILD DEPOSIT!!!! YES!!!!!! One of the top 10 ideas to have ever come out of this forum!!!

This ties to raids, but there needs to be a system where raid difficulty/rewards are tied to guild participation. Want to clear heroic AAT with 50 guys? Well its going to be harder but the rewards will be better. Only have 30 guys? Then you can get your Kenobi shards too, but the overall rewards will be less. Tuning raids for 50 people kind of stinks for a mobile game. If you have ever gone to the guilds forums its basically everyone looking to fill ranks.

Unifying Guilds - Much Needed Update

Nastynaz91
8 years ago
Don't agree with equal distribution on dailies. If I'm saving up energy, timing my collection of my free energy, and buying 5 refreshes to get the top spot, I don't want to get the same rewards as the guy who isn't even bothering with the activity
Versattio
8 years ago
To be fair, valid point.

What you're describing here, kind of sums up my gripe with the whole notion of SWGoH's guild system. A supposed 'guild activity', which requires you to internally compete for the top spot. It's really bad design, I mean I could understand if it was a guild vs guild challenge.
ARC-CaptainRex
8 years ago
GUILD DEPOSIT!!!! YES!!!!!! One of the top 10 ideas to have ever come out of this forum!!!
bigjsharkie
8 years ago
This ties to raids, but there needs to be a system where raid difficulty/rewards are tied to guild participation. Want to clear heroic AAT with 50 guys? Well its going to be harder but the rewards will be better. Only have 30 guys? Then you can get your Kenobi shards too, but the overall rewards will be less. Tuning raids for 50 people kind of stinks for a mobile game. If you have ever gone to the guilds forums its basically everyone looking to fill ranks.
Riktoven
8 years ago
I like all of these ideas.
vincentlondon
8 years ago
Give me all the coins from your guild. I ll keep 99% for me and 1% for others
Versattio
8 years ago
"The_Lazy_Pengu1n;848368" wrote:
This would be amazing except maybe rewards top guild members in raids a little more. If the top people carry the weight and then one low player who barely does anything get the same rewards, nobody will want to be in a guild

I agree and that would need to be factored in.

I suppose there could be a participation milestone that has to be reached in order to receive any kind of payout. If you don't reach it, you get nada and the system could be as simple as, X energy spend against Task Y.
Versattio
8 years ago
"bigjsharkie;848328" wrote:
This ties to raids, but there needs to be a system where raid difficulty/rewards are tied to guild participation. Want to clear heroic AAT with 50 guys? Well its going to be harder but the rewards will be better. Only have 30 guys? Then you can get your Kenobi shards too, but the overall rewards will be less. Tuning raids for 50 people kind of stinks for a mobile game. If you have ever gone to the guilds forums its basically everyone looking to fill ranks.

Yup. 50 actives who are geared correctly and high enough level is a big ask. Tailoring raid difficulty to 10, 20, 30 and 50 would be a nice addition to a guild rework. As you point out, the rewards could be smaller but ultimately you'd still be able to farm heroic shards.
Carth_Onassi1973
Seasoned Novice
8 years ago
"CaptainRex;848300" wrote:
GUILD DEPOSIT!!!! YES!!!!!! One of the top 10 ideas to have ever come out of this forum!!!

Guild deposit is an amazing idea.
pargame71
8 years ago
I like ideas, but I think like all good forum ideas will never be implemented