Okay first of all Ranked stats and normal game stats are totally different thing and they totally mean something different. Ranked stats means in your league how well you do, normal game means how well you do amongst ALL PLAYER BASE; you may encounter best player in apex, you may encounter the worst player so its just that.
If you like SBMM then play ranked all day even if they remove the SBMM then you will be always fighting in your skill range right ? Oh, you dont like that right? Nor do i since my casual games are now skrim lobbies! People putting down fences, holding buildings stressful games why do i want that when i want to chill ? Btw i am not that good of a player which brings another problem, i get farmed in every normal game lobby and in ranked. There is nowhere i can go from this? I cant play the game anymore because OBVIOUSLY i am not top tier player! So why the hell i am in these lobbies? Because i managed to get to Diamond? I got into diamond, i saw yeah predators are ripping me apart, there is no way i can move forward so stopped playing it. Then in my normal lobbies same thing happens. They are not in my skill level!
Oh one more thing, SBMM right well it is not applied within your squad! So i get the teammates which are lvl 20-50 s which has no idea about high tier matches (no coms, no pings, no info) and we get stomped on by pre made full 20-40k kill players. So how do you want me to enjoy this? Can you explain ?
Without SBMM my normal games were like; some games i dominate kill all, some games i got so outplayed and see their stats and laugh. Now every game i get killed by top tier players with crazy low tier teammates which drives me insane! I cant laugh about it anymore so i become toxic. I yell at people that are bad in this game and yeah they dont deserve this level of toxicity.
So 2 parts to this arguement;
1) Does that low tier players deserve to get * on in my lobby and become furious?
2) As a mediocore player do i deserve to get * on every match with useless teammates?
I think SBMM hurt players like me the most, the people who are in between being top tier players-averadge players. We have nowhere to have fun. Top tier players say oh its too sweaty yeah but you can still win, I can not. My team dies to any team we run into. So the only way for me to at least have some fun in normal lobbies is to find 2 more players and play as hard as we can to even contest. Man why do i need constant hardwork in a video game ?
------------Or better yet here is an example; think of yourself as okay player and you want to play a single player game that you lovveee to play. Next day it only allows you to play in the most hardcore difficulty which you cant progress in anything. How long are you going to try and keep dieing? or will you just say yeah thats it i dont want to see the endgame and quit? Thats exactly where i am now.
Then i get bored, create a smurf, then get into the normal lobbies and kill everyone, get 4k badge in the first match. Then farm trough the lobbies. Oh * it made the situation even worse for the new player base that wants to play this game right? Because there is so many people creating smurf accounts now! 1/2 of the lobby is lvl7 players with 70-100 kills. So how is the situation with the new playerbase? Its not fair to them, its not fair to me.
First of all you have to seperate 1-30 lvl 30-60lvl 60-100lvl 100+ lvl now there is 500 so there can be many different seperations and mine are just an example so yeah look at the data seperate lvl 500 s to lvl 100 s then apply sbmm amongst them(or dont apply, they spent the same amount of time in the game, so they should have similar experience). Otherwise this circle of life will continue and you will achieve nothing. It will just make players angry, smurf players will not buy skins, they will not buy skins to their mains because they cant use them.. it is certainly a loose loose situation.